The Impossible Astronaut

Discussions of the classic british sci-fi show.
Post Reply
HStorm
Fright Knight
Fright Knight
Posts: 2769
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:12 pm
Location: Salford, UK
Contact:

The Impossible Astronaut

Post by HStorm » Sun Apr 24, 2011 9:43 am

Seconds out, round two....

The second blessedly non-RTD-led series is up and running with a fairly interesting starter. First thing I should say is congratulations to Steven Moffat for finally giving the series the courage to shake up its own running format, and dare to open a season with a two-parter. One of the tiresome, formulaic qualities of NuWho so far has been that it always seems to follow the same order every year i.e. three single-episode stories to get started, a two-parter for episodes four and five, another run of single episodes for the mid-to-late stages etc. Breaking this needless and highly restrictive format is a simple act that could do a lot to keep the series fresh.

Moffat does seem to be developing some more unfortunate traits in his writing though. One of them is by-the-numbers hackery. The aliens in this are an example. The Silence look quite similar to the Ood, so they get no points for originality on the visual front, and also their powers have a very familiar echo to them. If we consider the Weeping Angels, they're creatures that only move when our heroes' backs are turned. These new aliens are creatures that no one remembers... as soon as our heroes' backs are turned. Don't get me wrong, it's not a bad idea, it's just it does sound a bit too similar to ground the series has already been over in the recent past, and it does lead me to question whether Moffat has any really new ideas left in the locker.

This question is reinforced by his insistence on once again having a story about events happening out of sequence (the Doctor of the future sending a message to the Doctor of the 'present' - such as there is one), more talk about 'spoilers' (a joke that was quite engaging on River Song's first couple of appearances, but nowadays I can imagine most of the audience singing along to a slow hand-clap, so predictable has it become), the Doctor hanging out with black-and-white-era movie stars (Marilyn Monroe in A Christmas Carol, now Laurel & Hardy), Amy again being pregnant (please don't let us have another round of her wandering about with a balloon stuffed up her shirt, a la Amy's Choice), a guest appearance by a prominent world leader, admittedly superbly played on this occasion (see Victory Of The Daleks), and yet another mysterious child figure making lots of arcane remarks, sometimes through electrical apparatus (remember the gas-masked kid in The Doctor Dances, and the computer in Silence In The Library, among others). Even the title sounds almost identical to The Impossible Planet.

The episode doesn't start too well. In fact, the scenes with the Doctor showing off by deliberately leaving a trail through recorded Earth history are silly and self-indulgent. Some of the dialogue in those first few minutes is also typical of the rebooted series in being smug and far too quip-heavy.

But once it stops trying too hard to be clever and punchy, it settles down a bit and actually starts being clever, and packs a really solid punch. The moment the 'old' Doctor is assassinated is quite a shock, and suddenly all the silly, forced light-heartedness is thankfully swept away. We have a story in progress at last. How about that?

It's quite easy to figure out, of course, that we would see the Doctor again very quickly. His declaration that he was two hundred years older than he was last time we saw him, coupled with experience of Moffat's constant 'timey-wimey' ideas, leaves us plenty of chance to predict the impending arrival of a younger incarnation. (The Doctor's slightly bitchy remark about Amy looking a bit heavier these days immediately makes her condition very clear too.) This scene is quite a bold risk on the part of the Mighty Moffat though, as it appears to discount the possibility of future regenerations. So if Matt Smith does choose to leave the series in the near future...

Get out of that one, Doctor Who. (Could’ve done without those uses of the series title in the dialogue, by the way, it’s needlessly demonstrative when the show does that.)

The friction aboard the TARDIS is fascinating, especially the Doctor making plain how little he trusts River. After all, what reason does he have to trust her really? The difficulty the other three have over whether to tell the Doctor about seeing his future self die leads to some real antagonism. At its core, I suspect, is the Doctor, usually the one who knows everything, suddenly being the only one aboard the TARDIS who isn't in on the secret. Usually the others all have to trust him, now he is being asked to trust them, and it's clear that his intellectual pride is bruised by the experience.

The character of Delaware is what really makes the episode for me. He's potentially an excellent foil for the Doctor, in that he shares the same boundless, open-minded sense of curiosity for the unknown (the wonder in his eyes when he enters the TARDIS is startlingly innocent given how cynical he is about individuals), but he also has a very grisly air of ruthlessness to him, that is clearly just below the surface. This paradoxical mix of cynicism and boyish enthusiasm somehow works, making him unpredictable, and therefore intriguing. He is also terrifically played by Mark Sheppard.

That the story is turning out not to be a Western after all is perhaps a shame, as the ground it is instead covering is, as I've already stated, somewhat derivative. It does allow it to have Richard Nixon in it though, which is kind of amusing, especially hearing all the hints at his arrogant paranoia littering his speech. Really, some of the people who've been elected to the Oval Office down the years. They'll be voting for some right-wing, alcoholic, draft-dodging, Texan born-again next.

No wait...

Never mind.

Somehow there's something just not scary enough about aliens in a dinner suit. Maybe they just remind me of how silly the Jagaroth looked in City Of Death, but so far, the Silence ain't doing it for me, just as the Human Dalek failed to affect my bladder-control in Daleks In Manhattan. It was very lurid the way the creature annihilated that woman in the lavatory though, and oddly chilling how even that sight just vanished from Amy's memory as soon as she was out of the door. The ending, with Amy apparently shooting a little girl in a spacesuit (possibly the future self of her unborn child? Perhaps) was rather shocking as well. I guess this episode certainly delivers in terms of startle-value, so we can't complain it's ever dull. Does it count as a cliffhanger though, seeing none of the regulars are definitively in danger? Yeah I'd say so. A moral cliffhanger is as valid as a physical one.

Possible bloopers; this incarnation of River appears, from what she says to Rory, to be younger than the one at the end of the last season, and yet she also seems to remember the business with the Pandorica. Also, she discusses the business of the Doctor's regeneration being interrupted. Amy and Rory seem to know what she's talking about, but they've never seen the Doctor regnerate before. Not necessarily a contradiction, but it does rather go against the grain; in the past, the Doctor has never really talked to companions about his power to regenerate unless they've seen it happening.

To sum up; not brilliant, but very, very absorbing, and as I say, it earns a bonus point for finally plucking up the courage to break series formula. In its own right, 7 out of 10. In this context, it just barely scrapes an 8.

User avatar
Pooka
Fright Knight
Fright Knight
Posts: 1032
Joined: Sun Nov 17, 2002 10:55 pm
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Impossible Astronaut

Post by Pooka » Sun Apr 24, 2011 12:35 pm

I kind of agree with the above analysis. A few other points that I thought were worth mentioning:

- Amy and Rory have a very nice house.
- Rory is used much better this time around. He still carries a slight unease about being a whole part of the team, but the Doctor sees him as more of a sidekick than just a plus one, and their dynamic is good too. I also love the Amy/Rory relationship - it works well on screen.
- River refers to the events of the Silence in the Library storyline (meeting the Doctor when he doesn't know who she is and subsequently dying) without knowing when that will be. Very clever indeed. In fact, I said, "Ah! Clever!" out loud.
- The Silence are terrifying, but I don't know why that one in the toilet had to kill Joy. He seemed to do so mostly because he could.

My predictions for the next episode based on speculation:

- Whatever the Silence did to Rory, he isn't dead. He's in the trailer for the next one, plus I went on a date with a girl who knows Arthur Darvill and told me he's in the whole series this time around. Or something like that. I forget exactly.
- River and Rory are in the bastard child of a TARDIS and that thing that Corden experiences at the end of The Lodger, complete with big lighty thing to put one's hand on.
- Amy isn't pregnant - or if she is, her child is that kid in the astronaut suit.
- Something happens with the picture on Amy's phone. They wouldn't put that in as a red herring. It's too obvious to be a red herring.
- Everyone develops a Batman fetish and they all decide to dress like Victor Zsasz - hence the tally marks.
- The Doctor is in the spacesuit and shoots himself to avoid any form of paradox. Or something like that. It's the sort of thing that would happen.

Anyway, I liked it. Thought it was great. I may slap my mother if she starts going on about how Matt Smith can't act, though. After every episode she says so. I like him, and it's getting irritating!
Pooka - teacher, writer, comedian, musician, geek, and full-time Knightmarian.

HStorm
Fright Knight
Fright Knight
Posts: 2769
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:12 pm
Location: Salford, UK
Contact:

Re: The Impossible Astronaut

Post by HStorm » Sun Apr 24, 2011 1:16 pm

I don't know why that one in the toilet had to kill Joy
Because a kill-joy is what he is? *Slaps thigh*

Sorry, been watching too much Motley recently...

HStorm
Fright Knight
Fright Knight
Posts: 2769
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:12 pm
Location: Salford, UK
Contact:

Re: The Impossible Astronaut

Post by HStorm » Mon Apr 25, 2011 8:34 am

Amy isn't pregnant - or if she is, her child is that kid in the astronaut suit.
Maybe that's a little too obvious?
The Doctor is in the spacesuit and shoots himself to avoid any form of paradox. Or something like that. It's the sort of thing that would happen.
I've thought about this, and I doubt that; three different incarnations of the same Doctor within a couple of miles of each other? Why?

My suspicion is that the entity in the spacesuit that kills the future Doctor is actually either River or Amy. It further occurs to me that River could be Amy's daughter grown up. That might explain how, in The Pandorica Opens, she was aware of who Amy was, even though it was a younger incarnation of River than the one who was supposed to be meeting her for the very first time in The Time Of Angels.

*Goes cross-eyed* I, er... hope people could follow that. Because I sure didn't.

Oh another blooper - when River shoots the Doctor's hat off, it flies off at an angle one hundred and twenty degrees different from the one it should have done.

BBrooks
Level 2 Dungeoneer
Level 2 Dungeoneer
Posts: 148
Joined: Fri Aug 28, 2009 11:04 am
Location: Market Harborough, Leicestershire
Contact:

Re: The Impossible Astronaut

Post by BBrooks » Mon Apr 25, 2011 3:38 pm

I loved it, Doctor Who is back with a bang and I too am glad that the format has been given a refreshing change. Opening with a two-parter (complete with a cliffhanger finale, for Part 1) is recapturing some of the feel of the Classic era. A typical NuWho opener is usually a rushed and rather silly affair ("New Earth" or "Partner's In Crime" anyone), but "The Impossible Astronaut" was much better. There was less rushing about, the whole plot was fleshed out more and that's why TIA had a unique and much different feel to it.

The Silents are certainly scary looking, but I agree with what Martin said about them looking similar to Ood's (who return later on in this series). So much so in fact, that when the first pictures of them appeared on Facebook, some fans thought they were Living Dead Ood's (That would have been good actually). :-) I also have to agree on the blatant rehashing of some old idea's too, the Astronaut looked very similar to the Vashta Nerada in Series 4. But apart from them, the episode still came across as being original and very dark.

The Future Doctor was played brilliantly by Matt Smith. That look of realisation & impending doom on his face when Delaware and The Astronaut appeared was excellent. I also liked how his death scene was filmed, at times it looked like we were seeing it all through the other character's eyes. I've just read some news on Facebook that we will be seeing yet another regeneration scene in next weeks episode. Mmmmm Interesting. Overall I give the episode a respectable 8 out of 10, probably the best opening episode of NuWho so far.

As for theories, it's hard to make them at this early stage. Although I would like to think that it was Paul McGann in the Astronaut Suit, who killed the Eleventh Doctor. :-) Speculation has been rife about him returning ever since he unveiled his new costume last October. In the official trailer for Series 6 there was a blink and you'll miss moment where you can clearly see Amy and Rory witnessing what looks like a Regeneration in the 9th/10th Doctor's Tardis. Could they be seeing Eighth regenerating into the Ninth? or is "Silence Will Fall" referring to the outcome of The Time War? in which it has been said that The Eighth Doctor had a hand in causing. Time will tell. :-D

HStorm
Fright Knight
Fright Knight
Posts: 2769
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:12 pm
Location: Salford, UK
Contact:

Re: The Impossible Astronaut

Post by HStorm » Wed Apr 27, 2011 7:54 pm

Ny boss at work is suggesting that the murder of the Eleventh Doctor is the crime River was imprisoned for in the first place.

Post Reply