Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightmare?

9inchsword · Post by **9inchsword** » 23 Jun 2003, 02:13

Or perhaps a new actor? his son, a women? discuss

Malefact · Post by **Malefact** » 23 Jun 2003, 02:23

I'd like to see Treguard in the new series. NO COMPROMISES!

Purgatory · Post by **Purgatory** » 23 Jun 2003, 02:26

it would never be knightmare with out him

9inchsword · Post by **9inchsword** » 23 Jun 2003, 02:33

According to an interview some onne did with him, he said he was too fat and old to play him again, he must be in his 50'ssssssssssssss

Purgatory · Post by **Purgatory** » 23 Jun 2003, 02:37

lol, does this meen that the idiot from Crystal maze is going to take his place? Ed someone lol NOOOOOOOOOO

Malefact · Post by **Malefact** » 23 Jun 2003, 02:55

Erm, that is not appropriate.

9inchsword · Post by **9inchsword** » 23 Jun 2003, 03:00

It was a play on Ed Tudor Pole, so yes it is

thompy · Post by **thompy** » 23 Jun 2003, 03:15

Yea, it would not be Knightmare without Hugo.

Fidjit · Post by **Fidjit** » 23 Jun 2003, 13:14

Nothing would replace Treguard but I can't beleive he called me a timewaster in Cliff's quest in series three

grumphicks · Post by **grumphicks** » 23 Jun 2003, 13:54

I think the crystal maze analogy is very true. It could be very bad without Hugo, ETP all over again. However, this does smack a little bit of old fans just getting a little misty eyed over the old program. If Tim Child's in charge I'm sure he'll know what's best.

My theory is be very faithfull to the original or rip it apart and start again

Dan · Post by **Dan** » 23 Jun 2003, 14:51

It was a play on Ed Tudor Pole, so yes it is

There is a difference between appropriate and apposite. In this case, what Malefact meant was that your post was inappropriate because of its lewd content.

Werewolf · Post by **Werewolf** » 23 Jun 2003, 15:02

I thought it was quite amusing actually...

And Grumphicks is right - the Knightmare format would just not work without Mr Hugo 'Ooh Nasty' Myatt. I think they should get him back, or change the format so that a new style of presenting is needed.

anagoge · Post by **anagoge** » 23 Jun 2003, 20:44

Easily sorted - Robbie Coltrane reprising his role as Hagrid. You know it'd work.

RoxxAatherton · Post by **RoxxAatherton** » 23 Jun 2003, 21:49

I recon there are some things that you just have to keep the same, the title, the idea that the dungeoner cant see and needs advisors and Treguard, he's just fundamental.

And I think its much more likely that they wont rip the old format apart and start anew because there's a risk of alienating all us ol' faithfuls...

If it aint broke, don't fix it, just make it more up to date!

Elessar · Post by **Elessar** » 23 Jun 2003, 22:33

Malefact:

Who are you to talk about what's appropriate and what's not? ;)

Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightmare?

Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightmare?

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Re: Would you want Treeguard back in a new Knightm

Who is online